Saturday, June 13, 2009

Truth Or Fiction?

One thing I've grappled with while working on this project is whether I should write the book as a true story--which requires substantial research--or write a novel that's based on the true story. There are advantages to doing it either way: For instance, if I decided to write a novel I could take the basic plot from the true story and enhance it in certain places that I think would make the narrative more dramatic than it actually was. Or I could just make stuff up to fill in parts of the story that are difficult to research. That'd be great.

However, totally factual, true stories always seem to resonate with readers in a unique way, and I think the story of our XC team and, in particular, the 1992 season is great on its own merits. No doubt, it's a harder path to go down because I've had to research a lot and interview several people, and still have to interview several more. Still, as I work my way through the writing, every now and then I have a little doubt about what I'm doing and entertain the idea of just fictionalizing the whole thing and making it a novel.

What prevents me from doing that, though, is that I keep coming back to the fact that when I decided to begin this project, I dug up all my old XC memorabilia and, of the four seasons I ran on the Wood Cross Country team, the 1992 season was the only one for which I had everything. I clipped and saved every newspaper article from that season, I held on to every meet result sheet our coach handed out to the team and saved every trophy or medal I won that year. I even found all the team clothing I wore that year. Some instinct in me--even though I don't specifically remember saving all of that stuff--knew the story of that season was a good one. At that time, I had no desire to be a writer, but I imagine I held on to all that stuff because, perhaps, some subconscious part of my brain figured I might need it someday.